video record titled ‘amandatodd.wmv’ changed into played on aydin coban’s pc
a defence lawyer for a dutch man accused of harassment and extortion of british columbia teenager amanda todd says sharing a hyperlink is “now not infant pornography.”
joseph saulnier told the jury in aydin coban’s b.c. ideal court docket trial there’s evidence that a video titled “amandatodd.wmv” turned into performed on a device seized from his client’s domestic, but it become now not stored as a records file.
coban has pleaded no longer guilty to extortion, harassment, verbal exchange with a younger individual to devote a sexual offence and possessing infant pornography when it comes to the port coquitlam, b.c., teen.
in final arguments, saulnier stated the evidence would not aid the existence of a facts file of child pornography of the alleged sufferer on the digital devices seized by dutch police.
earlier inside the trial, crown attorney marcel daigle noted testimony from a dutch officer who said a deleted video record referred to as amandatodd.wmv” have been performed on one of the devices in december 2010, corresponding with a time when todd changed into being actively careworn.
however saulnier stated the evidence “does not assist the lifestyles of a statistics report of infant pornography on amanda todd.”
the video changed into sent out as a link, but there was not anything to show it was stored as statistics on the seized gadgets, saulnier informed the jury on the second one day of his final arguments.
“can you look at this and be glad past an inexpensive doubt of the ownership of a records document of toddler pornography? no,” he stated.
crown legal professional louise kenworthy wrapped up her last arguments tuesday, pronouncing there has been a “treasure trove of statistics” linking coban to the harassment and extortion of todd.
however, saulnier stated tuesday, “fragments” of computer records mentioned by using police can not link the dutch guy to the harassment and extortion of todd.
he informed the jury that the identity of the person behind the messages and extortion can not be confirmed past an inexpensive doubt.
crown prosecutors allege coban is in the back of over 20 nameless online money owed that time and again burdened and extorted todd for sexually specific images and motion pictures.
on wednesday, saulnier argued that there was no proof that definitively linked the net accounts.
in the course of the trial, the crown has provided multiple pieces of evidence that include messages from nameless accounts to todd asking her to carry out “sex shows” or the harasser would ship express pics of todd to her pals and own family.
“i agree it’s now not a coincidence. this doesn’t suggest it’s the equal character,” he instructed the jury.
the defence attorney argued that differences in writing style and punctuation had been proof that one of a kind humans may be at the back of the diverse debts harassing todd.
saulnier additionally advised the jury that various fb debts that centered todd had operated on internet browsers that had been now not determined on the seized gadgets.
“that is a significant hole in crown’s principle,” he stated. “that is in reality evidence of human beings accessing these fb money owed from different gadgets, from other computers, proof of other humans using these facebook debts.”
there had been no cookies from facebook discovered at the seized gadgets, saulnier stated wednesday, referring to pieces of data that web sites use to track customers and their choices.
“even in case you manually or routinely delete your cookies for privacy, that [deleted] cookie, it goes to deleted space,” he said.
“finding a fragment would not imply that whoever had that tool is the writer of the message.”
saulnier also argued that the gadgets seized in coban’s residence did not necessarily belong to him.
“my submission in the evidence changed into that he repaired computers. he changed into a laptop guy,” he instructed the jury. “it does make feel that mr. coban, if he is looking at someone else’s device, he is going to connect it to something.”
all this evidence factors to a person else and not coban who become worried in the harassment and extortion of the youngster, he stated.
“for all the counts, the crown has not established past a reasonable doubt mr. coban is the writer of these messages. they have not demonstrated beyond a reasonable doubt mr. coban devoted those offences. i ask you to acquit mr. coban.”
justice martha devlin is scheduled to provide her very last instructions to jury contributors on friday before they start deliberations.